The approval of the first spot Bitcoin ETFs by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in January 2024 marked a historic moment for the financial and cryptocurrency sectors. This move legitimized Bitcoin as an asset class for a broader range of investors and triggered unprecedented institutional inflows.
But the journey to this approval was a long and arduous battle spanning over a decade. This article explores what would have happened if you had invested in Bitcoin itself at the very start of that journey—back when the first Bitcoin ETF was initially filed.
The Long Road to Bitcoin ETF Approval
The concept of a Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) was first introduced to the U.S. markets over a decade ago. Understanding this timeline is key to appreciating the significance of the eventual approval.
The First Filing: A Groundbreaking Proposal
On July 1, 2013, Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss, the founders of the Gemini cryptocurrency exchange, filed an S-1 application with the SEC for the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust. This was the first formal attempt to create a Bitcoin ETF, designed to track the price of Bitcoin and trade on a major stock exchange, offering investors a familiar and regulated way to gain exposure to the digital asset.
At the time of this filing, Bitcoin was a nascent asset, trading at approximately $90.80.
A Decade of Rejection and Setbacks
The SEC rejected the Winklevoss's initial application and a subsequent refiling in 2018. This began a multi-year period where numerous asset management companies saw their own Bitcoin ETF proposals delayed or denied by the regulator.
This prolonged refusal was a point of significant contention. On the 10-year anniversary of their original filing, Cameron Winklevoss called the SEC's stance a "complete and utter disaster for U.S. investors," arguing that it pushed investors toward unregulated offshore platforms, some of which later failed catastrophically.
The persistence of firms like Grayscale, which successfully sued the SEC over its rejection of their ETF conversion application, ultimately helped pave the way for the final approvals.
The Watershed Moment: January 2024
The regulatory landscape finally shifted in January 2024, when the SEC approved not one, but multiple spot Bitcoin ETFs from major institutions like BlackRock (iShares), Fidelity, and ARK Invest. This ended the long wait and opened the floodgates for institutional capital.
The Hypothetical Investment: $1,000 in July 2013
Let's analyze the potential returns of a strategic investment made at that pivotal moment in Bitcoin's history.
The Initial Purchase
On July 1, 2013, with Bitcoin priced at $90.80**, a **$1,000 investment would have purchased approximately 11.0132 BTC.
The Value Today
The growth of Bitcoin over the following 11 years has been extraordinary. With Bitcoin's price reaching new all-time highs and surpassing $100,000 in late 2024, the value of that initial investment has grown exponentially.
Based on a price of **$106,478.56**, the initial $1,000 investment would be worth:
11.0132 BTC × $106,478.56 = $1,172,669.68
This represents a staggering return of over 117,000% in just over 11 years.
Comparing Bitcoin's Performance to Traditional Assets
To fully contextualize Bitcoin's performance, it's helpful to compare it to returns from traditional stock market investments over the same period (July 2013 to present).
- S&P 500 Index (SPY): A $1,000 investment in the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust would be worth approximately **$3,736.80 today, a gain of about 273.7%**.
- Tesla (TSLA): Often cited as a superstar stock, a $1,000 investment in Tesla would have grown to roughly **$58,480.93, a phenomenal return of 5,748.1%**.
- Apple (AAPL): A $1,000 investment in the tech giant Apple would now be worth about **$17,035.49, a strong return of 1,603.5%**.
While these traditional equity investments performed admirably, Bitcoin's appreciation dwarfed them all, turning a modest sum into a life-changing amount of capital. For investors seeking the highest growth potential, this comparison highlights the unique value proposition that Bitcoin offered early adopters.
👉 Explore more strategies for identifying high-growth assets
The Current State of Bitcoin ETFs
Since their launch, Bitcoin ETFs have become a dominant force, attracting tens of billions of dollars in assets under management (AUM). Here are some of the top-performing funds by AUM:
- iShares Bitcoin Trust (IBIT): $53.9B
- Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund (FBTC): $21.0B
- ARK 21Shares Bitcoin ETF (ARKB): $4.9B
- Bitwise Bitcoin ETF (BITB): $4.1B
These products have successfully provided a secure and accessible gateway for both retail and institutional investors to add Bitcoin to their portfolios without the complexities of direct cryptocurrency ownership.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the first Bitcoin ETF ever filed?
The first Bitcoin ETF filed with the SEC was the Winklevoss Bitcoin Trust, submitted by Cameron and Tyler Winklevoss on July 1, 2013. It was rejected by regulators, beginning a long battle for approval that lasted over a decade.
How much would $100 in Bitcoin be worth if bought in 2013?
If you had invested $100 in Bitcoin on July 1, 2013 (at ~$90.80 per BTC), your investment would be worth approximately $117,266 today, based on a price of $106,478.56.
Why did it take so long for Bitcoin ETFs to get approved?
The SEC cited concerns over market manipulation, custody of assets, and investor protection as primary reasons for the long delays. The regulator required that these issues be addressed to their satisfaction before granting approval to any applicant.
Is it too late to invest in Bitcoin now?
While past performance is not indicative of future results, many analysts believe Bitcoin still has significant growth potential. The introduction of ETFs has broadened its investor base, and its fixed supply of 21 million coins continues to underpin its value proposition as a store of value. Always conduct your own research and consider your risk tolerance.
What is the difference between a spot ETF and a futures ETF?
A spot Bitcoin ETF holds actual Bitcoin, so its share price directly reflects the live market price of the cryptocurrency. A Bitcoin futures ETF holds contracts that bet on the future price of Bitcoin, which can lead to tracking error and other complexities compared to the spot price.
How do I choose a Bitcoin ETF?
Consider factors like the fund's expense ratio (management fee), the reputation of the issuer, the fund's liquidity (average trading volume), and its assets under management. Each of the major funds has slight differences that may make one more suitable for your portfolio than another.
The story of the first Bitcoin ETF filing is a powerful lesson in the potential of believing in transformative technology early. While few investments will ever replicate Bitcoin's historic run, its journey highlights the importance of innovation and long-term conviction in the financial markets.