Global Overview of Cryptocurrency Asset Licenses: Europe and America

The global fintech boom has placed the virtual currency asset market in the spotlight. Different countries and regions have developed unique regulatory frameworks and licensing systems based on their financial structures, regulatory goals, and market needs.

This article explores the licensing landscape for virtual currency assets in key European and American countries—the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Switzerland. We dive into their regulatory systems, policies, and the application requirements and scope of various licenses to provide comprehensive and accurate information for industry practitioners, investors, and those interested in cryptocurrency regulation.

United States

Regulatory System Overview

The United States is known for its complex, multi-layered virtual currency regulatory system, involving multiple federal and state-level agencies. These bodies enforce measures based on the function, nature, and use of virtual currencies.

Federal Level Regulation

1. Securities Law Regulation: The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) plays a key role by determining if a virtual currency qualifies as a security. If a currency meets the criteria of the Howey Test (investment contract test), such as through an Initial Coin Offering (ICO), it is treated as a security and must comply with the Securities Act. The SEC has taken action against unregistered ICOs and trading platforms to maintain market order and protect investors.
2. Commodity Law Regulation: The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) classifies major virtual currencies like Bitcoin and Ethereum as commodities and regulates their derivatives markets (futures, options). While the CFTC has limited direct oversight of spot markets, it holds enforcement power over market manipulation and fraud to ensure fairness and transparency.
3. Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing (AML/CFT) Regulation: The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) is the primary agency for AML/CFT oversight. It requires virtual currency exchanges and custodial service providers to register as Money Services Businesses (MSBs) and adhere to the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and Anti-Money Laundering Act (AML). These businesses must implement Customer Due Diligence (KYC) procedures and report suspicious transactions to prevent illicit fund flows.
4. Tax Regulation: The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) treats virtual currency as property, not currency, and taxes holdings and trades as capital gains. Using virtual currency to pay for goods or services may also create a taxable event. The IRS ensures tax compliance for virtual currency transactions, providing a stable revenue source for the government.

State-Level Regulation

U.S. states vary significantly in their approach to virtual currency. New York’s BitLicense is one of the strictest frameworks, requiring virtual currency businesses to obtain a license and meet specific compliance standards. Other states have adopted more lenient policies to attract cryptocurrency companies. This regulatory diversity presents challenges for businesses and has prompted efforts to establish a unified national framework.

Key Policies and Legislation

1. Digital Asset Market Structure Act (Draft): This bill aims to clarify the regulatory boundaries between security-type and commodity-type crypto assets, providing legal safeguards for the healthy development of the virtual currency market. Clear standards help reduce regulatory arbitrage and cross-market manipulation risks.
2. Digital Tax Compliance Act (DAC8): Focusing on tax transparency, this act requires virtual currency exchanges and wallet providers to report transaction information to tax authorities, helping combat tax evasion and improve compliance.
3. Executive Order: In 2022, the Biden administration issued an executive order on digital asset development, emphasizing innovation promotion and enhanced consumer protection. It calls for increased coordination among regulatory agencies to foster healthy market growth and safeguard consumer rights.

Main Licenses: MSB and BitLicense

1. Money Services Business (MSB) License

An MSB license is a registration and regulatory requirement for companies providing financial services like money transfers, payment services, or currency exchange.

• Regulator: Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), under the U.S. Department of the Treasury.

• Scope:

  • Money Transmission: Services moving funds from one location to another, e.g., cross-border payments via banks, wire transfers, or online platforms.
  • Currency Exchange: Services converting one currency to another, e.g., USD to EUR or CNY to USD.
  • Payment Instrument Issuance and Sale: Companies offering traveler’s checks, prepaid cards, or e-wallet top-ups.
  • Digital Currency Services: Including cryptocurrency trading, wallet services, and exchange of Bitcoin or other digital currencies.

• Requirements:

  • Registration: Must register as an MSB with FinCEN and comply with BSA and AML regulations.
  • Compliance Program: Develop and implement an effective AML compliance plan, including KYC and suspicious activity reporting.
  • Reporting Obligations: Submit regular reports to FinCEN, such as large cash transaction reports and suspicious activity reports.

2. New York State Virtual Currency License (BitLicense)

The BitLicense, or "New York State Department of Financial Services Virtual Currency License," is a regulatory framework launched in 2015 by the NYDFS to oversee virtual currency businesses operating in New York State. It comes in two types based on business activities:

• Virtual Currency License: For basic virtual currency businesses not involving fiat currency transmission.
• Virtual Currency and Money Transmitter License: For businesses handling both virtual currency and its exchange into fiat currency or transmission.
• Regulator: New York State Department of Financial Services (NYDFS).

• Scope: Companies in New York State engaged in:

  • Receiving, storing, and transmitting virtual currency.
  • Virtual currency exchange: Converting virtual currency to/from dollars or other currencies.
  • Virtual currency trading: Buying and selling Bitcoin and other virtual currencies.
  • Payment Processing: Services using virtual currency for payments.

• Requirements:

  • Capital Requirements: Meet NYDFS minimum capital requirements to ensure financial soundness.
  • Compliance Plan: Establish a comprehensive compliance and risk management plan, including AML, KYC, and cybersecurity measures.
  • Reporting Obligations: Submit regular financial and compliance reports to NYDFS.

👉 Explore comprehensive licensing guides

United Kingdom

Main Regulatory Framework

The UK (and Switzerland, covered later) is not an EU member and has its own independent virtual asset legal framework, separate from the EU’s MiCA regulation.

1. Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Counter-Terrorism Financing (CFT): Under the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (amended 2020), all virtual currency businesses must register with the FCA. Requirements include:

   • Customer Due Diligence (KYC): Verify user identities and assess transaction risks.
   • Suspicious Activity Report (SAR): Report suspicious transactions to regulators promptly.
   • Compliance Program: Establish internal control processes to meet AML/CFT rules.
2. Consumer Protection: Virtual currencies are not considered legal tender or financial instruments, so user funds are not protected by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS). The FCA has banned certain crypto derivatives (like CFDs and options) for retail investors to prevent significant losses due to high volatility.

3. Tax Policy:

   • Capital Gains Tax (CGT): May apply when selling virtual currency.
   • Income Tax: Profits from mining or receiving virtual currency as payment may be subject to income tax.
   • Value Added Tax (VAT): Some virtual currency transactions may involve VAT, but virtual currency used for payment is generally exempt.
4. Stablecoin Regulation: The UK plans stricter regulation of stablecoins, especially those used for payments. The Bank of England views stablecoins as a potential systemic risk, requiring transparent reserve assets and operational audits.
5. Market Abuse and Fraud Prevention: The FCA warns investors of high risks in virtual currency investments and encourages trading through registered service providers. Unregistered or unlicensed companies may be placed on the FCA’s warning list.

Key Regulatory Bodies

• Financial Conduct Authority (FCA): The core regulator for virtual currencies in the UK, overseeing crypto exchanges, custodial wallet providers, and more.
• Bank of England (BoE): Regulates stablecoins and payment systems, focusing on financial stability risks and leading research on a potential central bank digital currency (CBDC).
• HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC): Handles tax policies related to virtual currencies, including capital gains tax and VAT.

Main License: FCA Registration as a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP)

The FCA’s Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP) registration is a requirement under the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (amended 2020). It mandates that companies engaged in virtual asset-related activities register with and be supervised by the FCA. The primary goal is to prevent money laundering and terrorist financing while promoting transparency and compliance in the virtual asset industry.

1. Businesses Requiring a VASP License

• Virtual Currency Exchanges: Services exchanging fiat for crypto or crypto for crypto (e.g., Bitcoin to Ethereum).
• Custodial Wallet Service Providers: Services storing virtual assets, including private key management and digital asset security.
• Other Virtual Asset Services: Activities involving ICOs/IEOs (Initial Exchange Offerings), token sales, and related events.

2. Application Requirements

• AML and CFT Compliance: Must develop and implement a comprehensive AML/CFT plan, including:

  • KYC: Verify client identities and monitor transaction activities.
  • SAR: Report suspicious activities to the FCA.
  • Risk Assessment: Conduct dynamic risk assessments of clients and business relationships.
  • Data Retention: Keep transaction and KYC records for at least five years.
• Senior Management Review: The FCA conducts a "Fit and Proper" test on the management team, requiring compliance experience and clean ethical records, including criminal record checks and financial background reviews.
• Capital and Resource Requirements: Applicants must demonstrate sufficient financial resources and technical capabilities to support operations, with a clear business model and compliant funding plan.
• Compliance Officer Appointment: A dedicated Compliance Officer must be appointed to oversee AML/CFT policy implementation and report to the FCA.
• Cybersecurity and Technical Requirements: IT systems and cybersecurity measures must meet industry standards to protect client funds and sensitive information, with regular security audits and stress tests.
• Consumer Protection: Client assets must be segregated from company funds, and service terms and potential risks must be clearly disclosed to clients.

Canada MSB License

Key Regulatory Framework

1. Money Services Business (MSB) Registration: Since June 1, 2020, Canada has included virtual currency service providers (VASPs) in the MSB definition, covering:

   • Services exchanging virtual currency for fiat.
   • Services exchanging virtual currency for virtual currency.
   • Virtual currency transfer services.
2. Securities Law Application: Virtual currencies may be treated as securities or derivatives. Businesses like crypto asset exchanges must register with provincial securities regulators. Token offerings (ICOs/IEOs) must comply with securities laws if tokens have investment contract characteristics. Investment management involving virtual assets requires investment manager registration.

3. Tax Policy: The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) treats virtual currency as property, not legal tender. Requirements include:

   • Capital Gains Tax: Applies to the sale or exchange of virtual currency.
   • Income Tax: Mining income or receiving virtual currency as payment is considered taxable income.
   • Goods and Services Tax (GST)/Harmonized Sales Tax (HST): May apply to certain virtual currency transactions.
4. Consumer Protection: Virtual asset platforms must protect user funds, typically through custodial mechanisms, and clearly disclose transaction risks, prohibiting misleading宣传.
5. International Cooperation: Canada follows FATF standards for virtual asset regulation, ensuring alignment with international AML/CFT frameworks.

Main Regulatory Bodies

• Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC): Oversees AML/CFT for VASPs. All companies engaged in virtual currency trading or transfers must register as MSBs with FINTRAC.
• Canadian Securities Administrators (CSA): Regulates crypto asset activities involving securities or investment contracts (e.g., exchanges, investment platforms). Virtual currencies deemed securities must comply with provincial Securities Acts.
• Provincial Financial Regulators: For example, the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) directly regulates crypto asset platforms within the province.

Main License: MSB

The Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada (FINTRAC) regulates virtual currency-related businesses under the Money Services Business (MSB) license. Holders must comply with AML and CFT regulations.

1. Scope

Businesses requiring an MSB license include:

• Services exchanging virtual currency for fiat.
• Services exchanging virtual currency for virtual currency.
• Virtual currency transfer services (e.g., transfers, payments, clearing).
• Any other financial services involving virtual currency.

2. License Application Requirements

• Registration Requirement: Must register with FINTRAC as an MSB before commencing operations.

• AML and CFT Compliance: Must develop and implement an AML/CFT compliance plan, including:

  • Risk Assessment: Evaluate money laundering and terrorist financing risks based on the business model.
  • Customer Due Diligence (KYC): Verify client identities (ID, address proof, etc.) and monitor transactions for suspicious behavior.
  • Record Keeping: Maintain all transaction records and client information for at least five years.
  • Reporting Obligations: Submit Suspicious Transaction Reports (STRs) for unusual activities and report large virtual currency transactions exceeding CAD 10,000 to FINTRAC.
  • Compliance Officer Appointment: Designate a Compliance Officer to oversee the compliance plan.
• Technical and Security Requirements: Implement secure technical measures to protect client assets and data, with regular cybersecurity audits to ensure systems meet industry standards.
• Capital and Financial Requirements: Demonstrate sufficient financial resources to support operations and segregate client funds from company funds to avoid conflicts of interest.

👉 Learn more about regulatory compliance

Switzerland

Switzerland is renowned as a "cryptocurrency and blockchain haven." Its regulatory framework supports innovation while emphasizing financial stability and AML requirements. Switzerland adopts a technology-neutral principle, adapting existing laws to cover virtual currency and blockchain-related businesses.

Key Regulatory Framework

Switzerland’s regulatory framework is based on existing financial regulations, primarily:

1. Anti-Money Laundering and Counter-Terrorism Financing (AML): All businesses involved in virtual currency exchange, trading, custody, or transfer must comply with AML laws. They must register as financial intermediaries (through FINMA or a designated self-regulatory organization), implement KYC, and report suspicious transactions (STR).
2. Financial Market Infrastructure Act (FMIA): Tokenized securities (e.g., equity or bond tokens) are regulated under the FMIA. Any business providing trading platforms or custody services must meet securities trading or financial market infrastructure requirements.

3. Crypto Asset Classification: FINMA categorizes virtual assets into:

   • Payment Tokens: Primarily for payments or transfers, like Bitcoin and Ethereum; subject to AML regulations but not considered securities.
   • Utility Tokens: Provide access to a blockchain application or service; treated as securities only if they function as investment instruments.
   • Asset Tokens: Represent rights to assets (e.g., debt, equity, or physical assets); regulated under securities laws.
4. Blockchain and DLT Act: This act grants DLT-based securities the same legal status as traditional securities. It clarifies the legal responsibilities of DLT asset custodians and provides bankruptcy protection for custodied crypto assets.

Main Regulatory Bodies

• Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA): The primary regulator for virtual currency businesses involved in financial markets and services, especially those dealing with securities, payments, and banking. Its focus is on AML/CFT, investor protection, market integrity, and compliance with the FMIA and Anti-Money Laundering Act (AMLA).
• Swiss National Bank (SNB): Focuses on the potential impact of virtual currency on monetary policy and financial stability.
• Blockchain and Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) Act Implementation Bodies: Switzerland passed the DLT Act to regulate the legal status of DLT and crypto assets.

Main Licenses: FINMA

The Swiss Financial Market Supervisory Authority (FINMA) issues several licenses for virtual asset and financial services.

1. Banking License

• Scope: For businesses offering deposit services, crypto asset custody, and fiat exchange services. Cryptocurrency exchanges or platforms holding client funds typically need this license.

• Key Requirements:

  • Minimum capital requirement of at least CHF 10 million.
  • AML compliance, including implementing AML and KYC programs.
  • Effective risk control systems and internal audit mechanisms.
  • Strict segregation of client funds from company funds to ensure security.
• Regulatory Advantage: A banking license allows legal handling of client funds and attracts more institutional investors.

2. Securities Dealer License

• Scope: For trading platforms, brokers, or token issuers dealing with security-like tokens (e.g., asset tokens), providing securities trading, matching services, or tokenized asset sales.

• Key Requirements:

  • Minimum capital of CHF 1.5 million.
  • Regular submission of trade reports and financial data to FINMA.
  • Transparent operations ensuring compliance with FMIA transparency and fairness requirements.
  • Robust internal compliance programs to manage market and money laundering risks.

3. FinTech License

• Scope: For businesses involved in innovative financial technologies, such as blockchain, smart contracts, or DLT platforms. Allows acceptance of client deposits up to CHF 100 million but prohibits lending or interest payments.

• Key Requirements:

  • Minimum capital of CHF 300,000.
  • AML compliance with strong KYC policies.
  • Client fund protection with clear usage scope and custodial safeguards.
  • Technically secure and stable platforms.
• Advantage: Designed for small innovative companies, lowering the high barriers of traditional banking licenses.

4. Asset Management License

• Scope: For businesses managing virtual or traditional financial assets, including fund management companies or those handling tokenized assets.

• Key Requirements:

  • Capital requirements typically between CHF 500,000 and 2 million, based on assets under management.
  • AML and CFT policy implementation.
  • Regular reporting of asset management activities to FINMA.
  • Secure custody of client funds meeting bankruptcy protection requirements.
• Regulatory Advantage: Attracts high-net-worth clients and institutional investors, enhancing corporate credibility.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between an MSB and a BitLicense?
An MSB license is a federal registration with FinCEN focused primarily on AML/CFT compliance for money services, including crypto. A BitLicense is a state-specific license from NYDFS for businesses operating in New York, with stricter, comprehensive requirements covering consumer protection and cybersecurity in addition to AML rules.

Do all crypto businesses in the UK need to be registered with the FCA?
Yes, any UK-based business conducting crypto asset activities—like exchanging, transferring, or providing custodian wallets—must register with the FCA as a Virtual Asset Service Provider (VASP) to comply with anti-money laundering regulations.

Can a company operate throughout Canada with just one MSB license?
Yes, registration as an MSB with FINTRAC is nationally recognized. However, if the business involves activities classified as securities, it may also need to comply with provincial securities regulations and register with authorities like the Ontario Securities Commission.

Why is Switzerland considered favorable for crypto businesses?
Switzerland offers a clear, progressive regulatory environment that supports innovation. Its technology-neutral laws, diverse licensing options (like FinTech and banking licenses), and strong privacy and financial infrastructure make it an attractive hub for crypto and blockchain companies.

How does the SEC determine if a cryptocurrency is a security?
The SEC uses the Howey Test, which assesses if an investment of money is made in a common enterprise with an expectation of profits primarily from the efforts of others. If a cryptocurrency or token offering meets these criteria, it is classified as a security and must comply with federal securities laws.

What are the capital requirements for a Swiss FinTech license?
A Swiss FinTech license requires a minimum capital of 300,000 Swiss francs. This lower barrier compared to a full banking license (CHF 10 million) is designed to encourage innovation from smaller startups in the financial technology sector.

Conclusion

Europe and America display diverse characteristics in virtual currency asset regulation.

• The United States has built a complex, multi-layered system covering federal and state levels, using various acts to define regulatory scope. Its main licenses, MSB and BitLicense, apply to different virtual currency businesses with strict requirements for registration, compliance, and reporting.
• The UK centers its regulation around the FCA, using AML, consumer protection, and tax policies to oversee virtual currency companies. Its FCA VASP registration demands compliance across multiple dimensions to prevent money laundering and protect consumer rights.
• Canada includes virtual currency service providers in its MSB definition, regulated by bodies like FINTRAC. Its MSB license application involves registration, compliance, technical, and capital requirements under rules for money services, securities law, and tax policy.
• Switzerland, with FINMA as the main regulator, builds its framework on existing financial regulations, classifying virtual currencies for targeted oversight. Its banking, securities dealer, FinTech, and asset management licenses cater to different types of virtual currency businesses, offering various options for compliant operations.

Overall, these countries aim to balance innovation and risk in the virtual currency market, protect investor rights, and maintain financial stability. As the market evolves, regulatory policies will continue to develop and refine.