Introduction
Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) frequently employs processing techniques to enhance the efficacy and reduce the toxicity of raw herbal materials. Polygalae Radix (PR), derived from the root of Polygala tenuifolia Willd., is a renowned herb used for its calming and cognitive-enhancing properties. Often incorporated into health foods, PR undergoes specific processing methods to optimize its therapeutic benefits. The most common techniques include removing the xylem to produce Polygalae Cortex (PC), stir-frying PC with licorice (LP), and stir-frying PC with honey (HP). This article explores the chemical differences and antioxidant activities between crude and processed PR, providing a scientific basis for its application.
Understanding Polygalae Radix and Its Processing
Polygalae Radix, known as "Yuanzhi" in China, has been used for centuries to support mental clarity, dispel phlegm, and reduce swelling. Traditional beliefs suggest that the xylem (woody core) of PR contains components that may cause gastrointestinal discomfort. Consequently, the initial processing step typically involves removing the xylem, resulting in Polygalae Cortex (PC), which is the form most commonly available in markets and used clinically.
Further processing involves stir-frying PC with licorice or honey. Licorice processing is believed to reduce side effects like throat irritation and enhance the sedative and cognitive effects. Honey processing aims to retain the herb's cough-relieving and expectorant benefits while boosting its mind-calming properties and reducing potential toxicity.
Key Chemical Components in Polygalae Radix
PR contains a diverse array of bioactive compounds, which contribute to its pharmacological effects. The primary chemical classes include:
- Saponins: These are considered the main active constituents, known for their neuroprotective, sedative, and cough-relieving properties. They are oleanane-type triterpenoid saponins.
- Oligosaccharide Esters: These compounds exhibit significant neuroprotective, anti-dementia, and antidepressant activities.
- Xanthones: This class of compounds is characteristic of the Polygala genus and is noted for its antidepressant effects.
- Organic Acids: Small molecular compounds like ferulic acid and cinnamic acid contribute to the overall bioactivity.
- Carbohydrates: Present in smaller quantities, they are part of the herb's composition.
Processing methods can alter the content and profile of these compounds, influencing the herb's overall effects.
Analytical Techniques: UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS
Ultra-performance liquid chromatography coupled with quadrupole time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometry (UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS) is a powerful analytical tool used to identify and quantify chemical compounds in complex mixtures. Its high sensitivity, resolution, and accuracy make it ideal for studying the chemical profiles of herbal medicines.
In this study, UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS was employed to analyze and compare the chemical constituents of crude PR and its processed products (PC, HP, and LP). The analysis was conducted in negative ion mode, providing detailed insights into the molecular changes induced by processing.
Comprehensive Chemical Profiling
A total of 131 chemical compounds were identified across all samples. These included:
- 42 saponins
- 44 oligosaccharide esters
- 25 xanthones
- 2 organic acids
- 3 carbohydrates
- 15 components introduced from auxiliary materials (honey or licorice)
The Venn diagram analysis revealed that PC contained the highest number of unique compounds (17), compared to HP (8) and LP (7). Notably, 90 compounds were common to all four sample types, indicating a shared chemical foundation.
Processing significantly influenced the compound composition. For instance, honey processing introduced eight new compounds from honey, such as sucrose and diosmetin. Licorice processing added seven licorice-derived compounds, including liquiritin and liquiritigenin, which are known for their neuroprotective effects.
Impact of Processing on Compound Content
Multivariate statistical analyses, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA), Partial Least Squares Discriminant Analysis (PLS-DA), and Hierarchical Cluster Analysis (HCA), were used to visualize the differences between sample groups. These analyses clearly distinguished crude PR from processed products, highlighting the impact of processing on chemical profiles.
The heatmap analysis illustrated content variations for each compound. Key findings included:
- Crude PR showed higher content of 62 compounds, including Tenuifoliside B and Onjisaponin R.
- PC exhibited elevated levels of 75 compounds, such as Onjisaponin Sg and Tenuifoliose G.
- HP and LP demonstrated reductions in several saponins, oligosaccharide esters, and xanthones due to thermal and moisture exposure during processing.
The reduction in saponin content, particularly compounds like Onjisaponin B, is attributed to the hydrolysis of glycosidic bonds during heating, leading to the formation of less toxic components like Tenuifolin.
Total Bioactive Content and Antioxidant Activity
The study also evaluated the total phenolic content (TPC), total flavonoid content (TFC), total saponin content (TSC), and in vitro antioxidant activity using four assays: ABTS, FRAP, CUPRAC, and DPPH.
Total Phenolic, Flavonoid, and Saponin Contents
- TPC: PC had the highest phenolic content (12.345 mg/g DW), followed by PR, HP, and LP.
- TFC: PC also led in flavonoid content (78.467 mg/g DW), with LP, HP, and PR following in descending order.
- TSC: PC exhibited the highest saponin content (19.205 mg/g DW), while HP showed the lowest (14.435 mg/g DW).
These results indicate that removing the xylem (PC) concentrates or preserves these bioactive compounds, while further processing with honey or licorice leads to reductions.
Antioxidant Capacity Assessment
Antioxidant activity was consistently highest in PC across all assays:
- ABTS Radical Scavenging: PC showed the highest activity (23.983 μM/g DW).
- FRAP Reducing Power: PC demonstrated the strongest reducing capacity (16.065 μM/g DW).
- CUPRAC Method: PC again led with the highest value (48.663 μM/g DW).
- DPPH Radical Scavenging: PC exhibited the greatest scavenging efficiency (51.562%).
Correlation analysis revealed strong positive relationships between antioxidant activities and the contents of phenolics, flavonoids, and saponins. For instance, ABTS activity was significantly correlated with TFC and TSC, while FRAP and CUPRAC values were closely linked to TPC and TFC.
Implications and Applications
The findings underscore the importance of processing in modulating the chemical and antioxidant profiles of Polygalae Radix. Removing the xylem (PC) appears to enhance the concentration of beneficial compounds and boost antioxidant activity. Subsequent processing with honey or licorice introduces new compounds and may reduce toxicity but also decreases the content of some native bioactive constituents.
These insights are valuable for developing PR-based products in the food, cosmetic, and pharmaceutical industries. For example, PC could be preferred for formulations requiring high antioxidant capacity, while HP or LP might be chosen for their enhanced safety and specific introduced benefits.
👉 Explore advanced analytical methods for herbal extracts
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Polygalae Radix?
Polygalae Radix is the dried root of Polygala tenuifolia, a traditional Chinese herb used for its mental calming and cognitive-enhancing properties. It is also approved for use in health foods.
Why is processing necessary for Polygalae Radix?
Processing aims to reduce potential toxicity, enhance efficacy, and improve safety. Removing the xylem (wooden core) is believed to eliminate gastrointestinal irritants, while processing with licorice or honey adds complementary benefits.
How does processing affect the chemical composition?
Processing alters the chemical profile by reducing certain native compounds like saponins due to heat-induced hydrolysis. It also introduces new compounds from auxiliary materials, such as antioxidants from honey or neuroprotective agents from licorice.
Which form has the highest antioxidant activity?
Polygalae Cortex (PC), the form with the xylem removed, consistently demonstrated the highest antioxidant activity in this study, attributed to its greater concentration of phenolics, flavonoids, and saponins.
Can processed Polygalae Radix be used in dietary supplements?
Yes, processed forms like PC, HP, and LP are commonly used in clinical applications and proprietary Chinese medicines. They are considered safer and are often incorporated into dietary supplements and health foods.
Are the results applicable to product development?
Absolutely. Understanding the chemical and antioxidant differences helps formulators choose the most appropriate PR variant for specific applications, whether for cognitive support, antioxidant protection, or general wellness.
Conclusion
This comprehensive analysis using UPLC-Q-TOF-MS/MS revealed significant chemical differences between crude and processed Polygalae Radix. Processing methods distinctly alter the herb's composition, influencing its bioactive content and antioxidant capacity. Polygalae Cortex (PC) emerged with the highest levels of beneficial compounds and strongest antioxidant activity. These findings provide a scientific foundation for optimizing the use of PR in various industries, ensuring efficacy and safety in end products.