The year has been a record-setting one for Bitcoin, marked by unprecedented price surges and massive institutional adoption. However, this success story has not been uniformly shared across all cryptocurrency investment products. While U.S.-based spot Bitcoin ETFs have attracted historic inflows, their Canadian counterparts—the first such products launched globally—have faced significant headwinds and net outflows.
This divergence highlights the evolving dynamics of the crypto ETF market, where factors like geography, currency, fees, and regulatory environment play crucial roles in investor decision-making.
The Pioneers Face Challenges
In February 2021, Canada made financial history by approving the world's first Bitcoin ETFs. These products quickly gathered billions of dollars from both Canadian and international investors seeking exposure to the original cryptocurrency without the complexities of direct ownership. The early mover advantage served these funds well—until the landscape changed dramatically in early 2024.
When U.S. regulators finally approved spot Bitcoin ETFs in January 2024, it created an immediate shift in investor behavior. According to data compiled by TD Securities, Canadian Bitcoin ETFs have experienced net outflows of approximately CAD 578 million (USD 405 million) year-to-date as of mid-December. This makes cryptocurrency ETFs the only category in Canada to see negative flows in 2024, a stark contrast to the record USD 36 billion that poured into U.S. Bitcoin ETFs during the same period.
Why Investors Are Migrating
The migration of assets from Canadian to U.S. Bitcoin ETFs stems from several structural advantages that have become apparent since the U.S. products launched.
Market Preference and Liquidity
Vlad Tasevski, Chief Operating Officer at Purpose Investments Inc. (which launched the world's first Bitcoin ETF), notes that large U.S. and international investors naturally prefer U.S. ETFs because these markets serve as their primary trading venues for all other risk exposures.
"The U.S. is the largest capital market in the world, and that's where the majority of liquidity resides," Tasevski explained. "This shift was expected, though Canadian funds continue to serve specific investor needs."
The Fee Advantage
One of the most significant factors driving the migration is the substantial difference in management fees between Canadian and U.S. Bitcoin ETFs. The U.S. market launched with intensely competitive fee structures, with the largest Bitcoin ETF—the iShares Bitcoin Trust ETF—charging just 0.25%. Even the most cost-effective Canadian Bitcoin ETF (Fidelity's offering) charges 0.43%, while many others exceed 1%.
Tiffany Zhang, an analyst at National Bank, emphasizes that "fee differences and liquidity are actually the most important reasons Canadian investors prefer U.S. spot Bitcoin and spot Ethereum ETFs." The management fee differential, along with slight variations in the indices these ETFs track, can significantly impact long-term returns.
Structural and Timing Factors
The timing of these ETF launches explains much of the fee disparity. When Canadian Bitcoin ETFs debuted in 2021, Bitcoin was still a difficult-to-access asset class for many institutions. The higher fees reflected the operational complexities and limited competition at that time.
By the time U.S. regulators approved spot Bitcoin ETFs in 2024, the ecosystem had matured significantly. Bitcoin became more accessible, and intense competition among providers drove fees down to unprecedented levels. While some Canadian ETFs have since reduced their fees, U.S. ETFs benefit from greater trading volumes that make it easier to maintain lower cost structures.
👉 Explore current ETF performance metrics
The Canadian Advantage Persists for Some Investors
Despite the outflows, Canadian Bitcoin ETFs continue to serve important segments of the market, particularly domestic investors.
Currency Considerations
For Canadian investors, currency factors provide a compelling reason to keep investments within the country. The weakening Canadian dollar has made foreign investments more expensive, while Canadian Bitcoin ETFs can be traded in CAD and include currency hedging options.
Andres Rincon, Head of ETF Sales and Strategy at TD Securities, notes that "Canadian ETFs truly offer the option to manage currency risk over the long term, which is unique to Canadian ETFs." This currency management feature resonates strongly with investors who prefer to avoid additional foreign exchange exposure.
Domestic Investor Loyalty
Purpose Investments reports that while their Bitcoin ETF has seen outflows from international investors, net inflows from Canadian investors have actually increased slightly. Canadian investors now represent over 80% of the fund's approximately CAD 830 million in assets under management.
This domestic loyalty suggests that while fee differentials matter, they're not the only consideration for all investors. Convenience, familiarity with local providers, and currency considerations continue to play important roles in investment decisions.
Market Maturity and Strategic Behavior
The differing behaviors between Canadian and U.S. Bitcoin ETF investors may also reflect the relative maturity of each market.
Paul Cappelli, Head of ETF Strategy at Galaxy Digital, observes that "the Canadian Bitcoin ETF market is more mature than the U.S. market, so we're seeing investors being more strategic than the growth we saw early in the U.S. market." This maturity means Canadian investors may be more likely to engage in profit-taking and tactical allocation shifts rather than purely buy-and-hold behavior.
Cappelli adds that while U.S. Bitcoin ETFs have undoubtedly impacted the Canadian market, they're not the sole factor behind the outflows. "Profit-taking and other factors may influence individual investors' decisions," he noted.
Regulatory Developments Offer Hope
The upcoming U.S. presidential election has created optimism about a more crypto-friendly regulatory environment, which could benefit the entire ecosystem—including Canadian funds.
Cappelli points out that "since the U.S. election a month ago, interest in Bitcoin has increased, with nearly all metrics from flows to trading volume and price rising."
However, the post-election boost for Canadian cryptocurrency ETFs has been modest compared to their U.S. counterparts. The increase hasn't been sufficient to reverse five consecutive months of outflows from Canadian crypto ETFs since the U.S. products launched in January.
Future Outlook and Potential Developments
Despite the challenging year for Canadian Bitcoin ETFs, industry observers see potential for a more balanced competitive landscape ahead.
TD's Rincon believes the cryptocurrency ETF industry will experience more tailwinds as regulatory reforms from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission potentially pave the way for more diverse ETF products.
"If there are more cryptocurrency applications in the U.S., and some of those also transfer to Canada, I wouldn't be surprised," Rincon said.
This suggests that future product innovation—including ETFs based on other cryptocurrencies or more sophisticated crypto-based strategies—could reinvigorate interest in Canadian cryptocurrency ETFs, especially if they can maintain their first-mover advantage in new product categories.
The evolution of the global Bitcoin ETF market demonstrates how quickly competitive dynamics can shift in the cryptocurrency space. While early innovators face challenges from later entrants with structural advantages, the market continues to offer opportunities for products that serve specific investor needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are Canadian Bitcoin ETFs experiencing outflows?
Canadian Bitcoin ETFs are seeing net outflows primarily because U.S.-based alternatives offer lower management fees and greater liquidity. Many international investors have shifted their allocations to U.S. products since they became available in early 2024.
Do Canadian Bitcoin ETFs still offer any advantages?
Yes, Canadian Bitcoin ETFs provide currency hedging options for CAD-based investors and eliminate foreign exchange considerations. They also benefit from being offered by familiar local providers and may have different tax implications for Canadian residents.
How significant is the fee difference between Canadian and U.S. Bitcoin ETFs?
The fee difference is substantial. U.S. Bitcoin ETFs charge as low as 0.25%, while Canadian equivalents typically range from 0.43% to over 1%. This difference can significantly impact long-term returns, especially for larger investments.
Are all investors moving from Canadian to U.S. Bitcoin ETFs?
No, the data shows that while international investors are predominantly moving to U.S. products, Canadian investors have largely remained with domestic ETFs. Currency considerations and familiarity with local providers appear to be key factors in this decision.
What could reverse the outflow trend from Canadian Bitcoin ETFs?
Several factors could stabilize or reverse the outflows, including further fee reductions by Canadian providers, new product innovations, regulatory changes that advantage Canadian products, or significant currency movements that make CAD-denominated investments more attractive.
How has the U.S. election affected Bitcoin ETF flows?
The U.S. election has created expectations of a more crypto-friendly regulatory environment, which has increased interest in Bitcoin overall. However, this has primarily benefited U.S.-based ETFs thus far, with Canadian products seeing more modest improvements in flows.